REVIEW PAPER
Indications for computed tomography of the head in children following head trauma: shortcomings in the NICE, CATCH, SIGN, PECARN, and CHALICE guidelines
More details
Hide details
1
Department of Pediatrics with Clinical Assessment Unit, Medical University of Warsaw
Submission date: 2025-07-07
Acceptance date: 2025-09-15
Publication date: 2025-09-30
Corresponding author
Ernest P. Kuchar
Ernest Kuchar
Department of Pediatrics
with Clinical Assessment Unit
Pediatric Teaching Hospital
63a Żwirki i Wigury St.
02-091 Warsaw, Poland
Medical Studies 2025;41(3):155-160
KEYWORDS
TOPICS
ABSTRACT
Introduction:
Several guidelines exist for head computed tomography (CT) in children after trauma (NICE, CATCH, SIGN, PECARN, CHALICE), but they differ significantly, potentially leading to inconsistent diagnostic practices.
Methods:
We analyzed and compared CT indication criteria across the five guidelines, focusing on differences, omissions, and unclear definitions. No human/animal subjects; IRB approval not required.
Results:
Only few indications was common to all five guidelines. For example, “warfarin use” is included only in NICE (and excluded in PECARN); “irritability” appears only in CATCH, while “severe mechanism of injury” is emphasized by PECARN, NICE, and CHALICE, but poorly defined. Several symptoms (e.g., “worsening headache”) lack clear definitions. None of the guidelines explicitly address multisystem trauma.
Conclusions:
Current pediatric head CT guidelines are inconsistent and have important limitations. Harmonization and clarification of vague terms are recommended to improve decision-making and patient safety.
REFERENCES (12)
1.
Easter JS, Bakes K, Dhaliwal J, Miller M, Caruso E, Hau- koos JS. Comparison of PECARN, CATCH, and CHALICE rules for children with minor head injury: a prospective cohort study. Ann Emerg Med. 2014; 64(2): 145-152.
3.
Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN). Early Management of Patients with a Head Injury – Quick Reference Guide. Edinburgh: SIGN 2009. Available from:
https://www.sign.ac.uk/assets/....
4.
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE). Head Injury: Assessment and Early Management. NICE Guideline NG232; May 2023. Available from:
https://www.nice.org.uk/guidan....
5.
Osmond MH, Klassen TP, Wells GA, Correll R, Jarvis A, Joubert G, Bailey B, Chauvin-Kimoff L, Pusic M, McCon- nell D, Nijssen-Jordan C, Silver N, Taylor B, Stiell IG; Pediatric Emergency Research Canada (PERC) Head Injury Study Group. CATCH: a clinical decision rule for the use of computed tomography in children with minor head injury. CMAJ. 2010; 182(4): 341-348.
6.
Gambacorta A, Moro M, Curatola A, Brancato F, Covino M, Chiaretti A, Gatto A. PECARN rule in the diagnostic process of pediatric patients with minor head trauma in the emergency department. Eur J Pediatr. 2022; 181(5): 2147-2154.
7.
Dunning J, Daly JP, Lomas JP, Lecky F, Batchelor J, Mackway-Jones K; Children’s head injury algorithm for the prediction of important clinical events study group. Derivation of the CHALICE decision rule for head injury in children. Arch Dis Child. 2006; 91(11): 885-891.
8.
Ak R, Celik NB, Erdogan HD, Karaküçük AY, Gökdoğan S, Korkmaz S, Seyhan AU. Evaluation of three clinical decision rules in pediatric patients with minor head injury: PECARN, CHALICE and CHATCH. Glob Emerg Crit Care 2023; 2(2): 33-40.
9.
Arneitz C, Sinzig M, Fasching G. Diagnostic and clinical management of skull fractures in children. J Clin Imaging Sci. 2016; 6: 47.
10.
Ramaiah R. Pediatric trauma – broader perspectives. Austin J Anesth Analg. 2014; 2(2): 1012.
11.
Haydel MJ, Weisbrod LJ, Wajeeha W. Pediatric Head Trauma. StatPearls Publishing; 2025 Jan-.
12.
Peclet MH, Newman KD, Eichelberger MR. Thoracic trauma in children: an indicator of increased mortality. J Paeditr Surg. 1990; 25(9): 961-966.